Research Spotlight: What if their worry is realistic?

What if a young person’s worry reflects a real risk or something they’ve experienced before? Drawing on Farley and colleagues’ paper, we explore how CBT can acknowledge these realities, support coping and keep the young person’s circumstances at the centre of the work.

15 Oct 26

Reflections on Farley and colleagues’ “What to Do When Worries Ring True”.

“But what if their worry is realistic?” “What if the thing they’re afraid of has happened before?” These questions come up frequently when considering GAD presentations in children and young people. And for good reason. Understanding the experiences behind a young person’s worries is an important part of deciding how best to support them.

A child might worry about a parent who is seriously unwell. A young person might fear rejection after repeated experiences of discrimination. Someone who has been bullied may have understandable concerns about returning to school.

Their circumstances matter to how we understand their anxiety and how we approach the work together.

Farley and colleagues’ paper, *What to Do When Worries Ring True: How CBT Clinicians Can Address Realistic Worries When Treating Youth With Anxiety*, explores this thoughtfully, with practical examples of how core CBT strategies can be adapted.

The paper brings together principles central to thoughtful CYP CBT, with practical examples that illustrate the clinical judgement involved in applying them.

Start with the context surrounding the worry

Before deciding whether a thought reflects an overestimation of danger, we need to understand the young person’s circumstances. What have they experienced? What is happening now? What do they know about the situation that we might not yet understand?

Questions to explore might include:

  • “Can you tell me about a time when this happened?”
  • “What is happening at the moment that makes this feel possible?”
  • “What do the people around you think about this situation?”
  • “Is there anything about this that you think I haven’t understood yet?”

Information from parents, carers or other relevant people may also help build that understanding, where appropriate. Assessment remains an ongoing process as trust develops and more of the young person’s story emerges.

Be thoughtful with “false alarm” explanations

The idea of an over-sensitive alarm can help explain some experiences of anxiety. But when a young person faces a genuine threat, describing their response as a false alarm may leave them feeling misunderstood.

The authors suggest explaining the body’s response to fear and stress in a way that acknowledges the young person’s circumstances. We can explore the connections between thoughts, physical sensations, feelings and actions while recognising why the situation feels threatening.

This also leaves room to explore which responses offer protection and which may be adding to distress or restricting everyday life.

Explore the impact of a thought alongside its accuracy

When a feared outcome is genuinely possible, gathering evidence may not lead to the reassuring conclusion a practitioner expects.

The paper describes how cognitive work can instead explore the helpfulness of a thought and its effects on feelings and behaviour, particularly when a situation has no clear or immediate solution.

That needs care too. Describing a thought as “unhelpful” should open a collaborative conversation about its impact. The young person’s perspective is central to that judgement.

Useful questions might be:

  • “When this thought shows up, what happens next?”
  • “Does thinking about it this way help you take any useful action?”
  • “What parts of this situation can you influence?”
  • “Is there another way of holding this worry that acknowledges the difficulty and helps you cope?”

For example, a young person worried about a parent’s illness may need space to acknowledge uncertainty, identify support and stay connected with everyday activities. A coping perspective can recognise that the situation is difficult without promising that everything will be fine.

Be clear about the purpose of exposure

The authors also explore how exposure can support young people whose fears have a realistic basis. Their examples focus on helping young people return to meaningful activities that anxiety has restricted, with appropriate attention to actual risk.

In a food-allergy example, exposure targets avoidance extending beyond medically advised precautions; it preserves the precautions needed for physical safety.

This distinction matters. Planning needs to establish what is safe, what appropriate precautions involve and what the young person hopes to regain. Relevant professional advice may be needed, as in the allergy example.

Questions for formulation and supervision include:

  • What is the young person avoiding, and what function does that avoidance serve?
  • Which precautions are necessary in this context?
  • What valued activities have become harder to access?
  • What learning are we hoping the task will support?

Consider what needs to change around the young person

Some difficulties call for practical action alongside therapeutic work.

Bullying may require a response from school. A young person with learning needs may need adjustments and support. Concerns about safety may require safeguarding action or involvement from other services.

The paper highlights the role of advocacy and environmental support alongside individual coping skills. Our formulation needs room for both: the patterns that maintain anxiety and the circumstances contributing to it.

Reflect on our own reference points

A particularly valuable thread throughout the paper is the importance of clinician self-reflection.

Our experiences influence what feels ordinary, threatening or manageable to us. Something we have never had to consider may be a recurring concern in a young person’s life. Equally, a familiar experience may lead us to assume we understand more than we do.

Two questions worth taking into supervision are:

  • Whose experiences am I using as my reference point?
  • What might I be assuming about this young person’s world?

Keeping CBT connected to the young person

The paper offers a clear account of the judgement involved in applying CBT thoughtfully: understanding context, working collaboratively and adapting the delivery while retaining the principles behind the intervention.

At CBT Hub, we recommend this paper to practitioners, trainees and supervisors working with CYP anxiety. It offers plenty to reflect on, with concrete examples to explore in practice, training and supervision.

Original paper

*This blog shares reflections on a practice-focused paper. The authors’ recommendations draw on existing literature and clinical examples; the paper does not test these adaptations in a new treatment trial. They also distinguish this work from treatment for trauma-related symptoms requiring a trauma-focused intervention.*